Tuesday, October 6, 2009

Predictions

I'm always amused when financial gurus attempt to predict the future by looking at the past.

I recall looking at the monthly returns of the S&P500, over a 10 year period (from the 1950s to the 1990s).

From these 600 monthly returns I select 120 of 'em.
(That makes 10 years, right?)
Then I plot the evolution of a portfolio using this random selection of 120 returns.
Then I pick another random set of 120 returns,
Then I get this (where the white curve is the result of a random selection):


Now comes the big question
What will the next ten years look like?



In spite of this distain for predictions, I enjoy doing it meself.
For example, I look at the gain made by some stock over the past month.
Then I look at the historical monthly gains for that stock.
Then I identify the historical "best fit".
Then I see what happens in the next month (historically speaking).
Then I use that to predict what'll happen in the next month, starting today.

My brother-in-law owns CBQ.
It invests in Brazil, Russia, India and China.
It closed yesterday at $27.75.
With optimal confidence, I predicted it'd hit $31 in the next 2 weeks:


-------------------------------------

I forgot to mention this one, where you're given some historical (weekly) data and asked to guess, like this:

Then you get the actual (historical) continuation, like this:


That ain't easy !!


 

No comments:

Post a Comment